Monday, September 27, 2010

Is it about the Journey or the Destination?

So I like stories with twists or surprise endings where the author sets us up to believe one thing is going to happen or victory can only be had one way but in the end the protagonist finds another way. I also like stories where the antagonist forces the good guys hand in some way. I even like when the end comes and the protagonist has a change of heart, doing something a little out of character that shocks me.

What I really like about a story is what happens between points A and B. The trials and tribulations of the journey. Now the journey doesn't always have to be about traveling from here to there. It can be the characters journeys from a dark place to a better life. It might even be a characters trek down a dark path. Maybe it's about all the different people the characters help along the way. All the problems they solve as they travel to the destination to destroy the ultimate evil of ultimate destruction.

In gaming terms, all those little adventures along the way could mean a lot more at the end because the world your saving now has a face. If the players fail at the end then all those people they helped along the way will die or be subjugated by the ultimate evil. The players can have that extra motivation or you can put it on them by having those innocuous one off adventures in the middle of your big adventure. The small stories can and should play into the big tale. Saving the millers daughter from the hobgoblin bandits means something when the town throws you a party and the daughter becomes one of the characters sweethearts. The town matters more when they come back through and everyone remembers them and cherishes them for what they've done. A little hero worship is good for the players and invests them in NPC's, gives them emotional attachment.

Now a town is just one touch. Traveling merchants who might be willing to share a meal, a lone hermit with a bit of wisdom and a good disposition, another adventuring party who the players compete with on a friendly level. Don't be afraid to add these touches to your game. It'll be worth it when the end comes and the players characters have something worth fighting for.

Good night and good gaming.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Cultivating good players

So I've been noticing a trend lately with some of my friends who say they're A list gamers. I don't believe in A list gamers, F list gamers, or anything in between. I think there are gamer types people prefer to play with. I've run game for all types from power gamers, to storytellers, to improv people, to rules guys, to dice rollers, to passive watchers. Heck, just pick up any of those guides to game mastering with the sections on different stereotypes of gamers. I've run game for them all and probably for a few they haven't defined yet. My question to those A list gamers out there is if they think they're so good at what they do why aren't they showing other gamers how to play like them? Why not cultivating them into what they believe are A plus gamers?

I have my own idea's about what makes a great game. I also have my own idea's about how I want to run a game. Not only do I try and project those idea's onto the people I'm running game for but I also listen to them. The players will have there own idea's for what makes a great game. They'll have there own wants from a game. As a game master you need to take their idea's and wants and meld them with your own. This helps you grow as a game master and will show the people your running game for new idea's. It's honestly an enlightening experience and very satisfying.

Time for some honesty. I like 4e D&D. I like it for all the same reasons that Keith Baker likes it. If you want to hear some of his thoughts on 4e D&D and gaming in general go check out the Bear Swarm podcast, episode 122. It doesn't have much to do with cultivating players but it can shed some light on the true flexibility of 4e and any game system if you give it some thought. Here's the link:

http://www.bearswarm.com/episode-122-gencon-keith-baker

D&D 4e can be anything you want it to be along with that tactical combat experience. Reason I'm using 4e D&D as the example is because I've been running a 4e campaign for 2 years. This campaign is the game I've used to change my own GMing style and cultivate a group that I enjoy playing with more than all others.

Two years ago, When we started, this was the first 4e campaign I decided to run. It was based off an idea I had from 3.5 campaign that I started but fizzled out. I rebooted the idea using 4e and it took off. My group was a bunch of 3.5 players that were interested in playing a game I was running on the word of their long time 3.5 DM. He'd played in some games I'd run and liked me as a GM. Knowing they were mostly hack and slasher/ power gamer character builders I crafted a pilot game with those idea's in mind. I also used a mercenary company to keep them as a group so they could have differing interests yet still would work together. Basic RPG concepts, play to the crowd and give them a light reason to hold them together. Over time I kept introducing elements from other games and idea's they and I weren't used to using. Narrative control is one example of this. Here's what I did:

I'd come to several points during this campaign where they had the choice to go different ways in the story. They would choose and I would write the adventure. Those have been the best games of the campaign. Why? Because they got pick and weren't led anywhere. They were invested in their choice. Yeah, it's a basic concept but it taught me and them some things we didn't know about gaming before. I didn't drop a hook or several. I let them create the next plot point and fleshed it out. The concept I got from this is "Run the game they want your way". That's just one of the many many things we've all learned from this game over two years.

Today I have people playing characters who care about a world, story, people and places that feel real to them. They have families and friends, characters who have experienced loss and pain, characters who've loved, schemed, developed, changed, progressed, died, come back from the dead, and committed suicide of their own volition. The players aren't just the hack and slashers they came to the table as. They're storytellers and thespians too. They find more out of the game then building a leet character and dealing epic damage or instawinning the encounter.

Because of their character building skills and power gaming style I've found ways to make more challenging and interesting encounters. I push the limits of my players within the rules and push story and improve theater into my encounters. My bad guys are more life like and hated. My NPC's are more real and diverse. I credit my players for having their preferences and play style while playing off my cues and NPC's. It's a cycle for a GM and the players. If you pay attention you can give players something to take from your games and you can gain things from them. So bring your idea's to the table and listen to theirs. In the end you'll grow your group into a well rounded gaming group. Besides, killing monsters and taking treasure is fun, but years of it isn't.

Good Night and Good Gaming

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Don't fight the police

So there's a saying that Jim Rome of Talk show fame uses quite often whenever some athlete gets in trouble with the law.

Don't fight the police because they have friends.

If you don't get what it means it's ok. I'll explain.

So if the game your playing has some sort of civilization there will probably be law enforcement agencies associated with it. Now your typical law enforcer might not be much all alone but when it comes to those guys they always have friends they can call on. If it's a modern or future tech game those friends are just a radio call away and if it's a lower tech game then the posse can get mounted up and constantly hound the offenders until they're caught or killed. Plus there's always that network of wanted posters and criminal wanted lists that float around civilized countries, governments, and organizations. Law enforcement is just another organization you can use to hound your players and the best part about this one is they have the law on their side because, well, they are the law.

Now think about how angry people are when someone attacks a police officer. Think about what happens to someone who attacks a cop and then gets arrested. They generally come out with a whole lot more bruises than they went into the clink with. A lot of us might think rebelling against law enforcement agencies is a romantic idea, and it is, but what happens when you inject a little reality into your games. If your players want to fight the law the law should really kickem in the head and give them a beat down because they aren't the bumbling idiots they tend to be depicted as in our entertainment media.

Law enforcement agencies have something else going for them. They're well equipped and trained. Their skill sets are in the ass kicking spectrum. Even that moderately over weight cop who likes donuts and coffee knows how to shoot his gun a lot better than your average joe and probably better that the punk who owns an illegal weapon. Part of these guys jobs is to train and keep in shape. They drill and workout. They get time on the shooting range. They spar. They tend to be units who work well together. They're tight.

Remember how I was talking about how you shouldn't fight the police because they have friends. Well what happens when the shit hits the fan and the regular law enforcement can't handle the situation. You go up the ladder and start calling in the heavy hitters. SWAT comes to mind for local law enforcement but if you you start messing with governments and those levels of organizations you start running into the CIA, FBI, and NSA level groups and they are generally verified bad asses and not just because they can beat you senseless. They have resources beyond what local government could have, information streams that reveal your players hiding places, friends, families, and those other things that matter to you. At that point you can start using Big Brother to keep your players on their toes and have a reason to be one step ahead of them. You can create that sense of paranoia and insecurity. Work it into a lower tech setting and you can have the dark lanterns as they do in Eberron or the Marshals like they did in the Wild West. Be creative but make them threatening because they shouldn't be pushovers.

To close I'd just like to say using law enforcement as an antagonist can be fun but you need to be careful to not over do it and frustrate your players. Still. If you happen to have a group of players who like to ignore the law in civilized places and start bar fights just arrest them, thrown em in a holding center with some of the drug dealing assault charged, doped out scumbags of your world and don't be afraid to have them sleep in urine, preferably not their own.

Good Gaming and Good Night

Monday, August 30, 2010

Damage Threshold and Wound rules for 4e

So your combats take way to long in your 4e games and you wanna shorten them. Well if your good at math and don't mind doing a little division then you can use this system.

So instead of hp you can give your bad guys a number of hits or wounds they can take and a damage Threshold.

So how does it work?

It's actually pretty simple. Players still do normal damage as they would with powers and such but once you hear the damage you divide the number by the damage threshold and round any excess up. That's how many wounds you deal to the bad guys.

So how do you figure out how many wounds a monster has?

These are the numbers I'm messing with right now.

Brutes 12 Wounds
Skirmishers 8 Wounds
Controllers 8 Wounds
Lurkers 6 Wounds
Soldiers 10 Wounds
Artillery 6 Wounds

The Damage Threshold is pretty simple. I just use the creatures level plus 10 for standard, elite, and solo monsters.

For minions I use level plus 5 and this gives me the option of making minions who are a little tougher or mega minions as I call them with 2 or 3 wounds but they still go down pretty easy.

Those are the base numbers I use but there's no mathimatical formula I've come up with. It's more of a feel and need thing. You want a tough zombie make the damage threshold higher or tack on a rule that says you can make a called shot for the head which kills them instantly but imposes a negative five penalty on the attack roll or even a negative 10 if you think it'd be really hard to hit that specific type of zombie in the head.

I do really fast D&D math but doing all the large number subtractions in my head is time consuming and hurts my head after a while. This happens at paragon and epic tier combat. It's just faster for me to do the division and mark off some ticks on my note tracking sheets. When the monsters are at half their wounds then they're bloodied.

I've also went to the idea of using average damage plus five per tier for the bad guys. Players don't care too much about how much damage the bad guys do. They care more about what they're doing and how cool they are. Hopefully you have enough different baddies from encounter to encounter so the players can't game the game from the average damage. Plus there's nothing wrong with the players using information gained in the game to help themselves later. If you know about how hard certain people or things hit then you can set up that take a hit to deliver a hit situation. If you don't like the idea of non variable damage then just take the average damage and roll a d10 and add that to the roll.

Good Gaming and Good Night.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Choice and Motivation

I do love running games. It's what I do the most. So get better at running games I've done a lot of reading of forums, blogs, and books and I've come to some important conclusions and found most people agree on the things you should do and not do. One of the big ones is RPG's shouldn't be railroaded games. Don't dictate the story to your players. You shouldn't write out a script. If your gonna run a game like that then go write a screen play.

Well ok. I know what not to do but no one really told me how to avoid this? I feel a lot of people gloss over that part with there advice. I don't know why. Maybe no one has ever quantified it well enough for everyone to agree on. Maybe there are many different styles and ways to avoid dictating story. I don't really think there are. I think it boils down to a couple things.

Choice and Motivation.

If you can give your players choices, especially ones motivated by who their characters are and what the characters care about, then your players are helping craft a story about them. So how does one craft a scenario to give their players choices that help in crafting the story? This is how I would do it.

Set up a situation where the antagonists to your players are trying to accomplish something and the players goals are opposed to the antagonists.

If this seems vague to some of you it is and by design. It's a concept you can use and apply to any style of game. So how do you implement this idea? Find out what your players motivations are, what they care about, and what interests them. Then make the antagonists goals the same as the players motivations, threaten what the players care about, or surround the game with what the players are interested in. You will create tension and conflict in your game developing drama and stress leading to action and choices.

So there's the concept and here's an example of how I implemented this idea to motivate the characters of a campaign I'd been running. The setting is fantasy and here's the Plot.

A mind flayer has a hidden lab in the mines of a mining town. He's been doing flesh warping experiments on the local wildlife, the random lost child who wanders into the mine, and the occasional miner who doesn't come back from a bathroom break. He's been given the go ahead by his boss to take the whole mining town and turn them into a flesh-warped army. Using his constructs and flesh-warped creations he manages to subdue or kill every person in the mining town in one night and turn the place into a ghost town with his constructs as guardians. The mines also serve as a raw material resource and the mind flayer plans on getting as much out of the mine as possible before the kingdom interferes. He has time since the mind flayers boss is keeping the kingdom busy for as long as possible from the inside. If nothing happens to interfere with the mindflayer it creates several hundred aberrant creatures and begins to expand from the mining town into the surrounding area causing more problems.

The players get involved when they're asked to find out what happened to an agent of a secret council they're friendly with. He'd stopped sending communications a week and a half ago and was stationed in the mining town. I'd set this up previously since the players had been to the mining town before and made friends with some of the locals. They were especially fond of a young boy named Dusty. It is also important to note that in the first story arc of the game the primary opponents to the players were a band of robin hood like rogues called The Knaves of Belard and the mining town is on the edge of their territory. They'd stopped a Knave plot but not the organization as a whole.

The first encounter sets the stage for the rest of the adventure. The players run into Dusty who's running through the woods of the Belard forest being pursued by some of the Knaves of Belard. Dusty is being pursued because he's slowly changing into an aberrant creature known as a choker. The Knaves have been doing everything they can to contain the horrors that have been leaking out of the Mining town. One of the things they've learned is once you start changing you can't change back. This isn't true but the Knaves haven't found a way to reverse the effects yet.

So in the first encounter I've given the players some choices and stresses.

First, an NPC they're fond of is changing into a monster. They have time but not a lot to try and find a way to change him back. It's someone they care about and for some saving this kid is part of there character motivation. Making up for things they've done in their past. Righting wrongs. Stuff like that.

Second, they have to either convince these Knaves to let them try and help Dusty or fight the Knaves. Both have consequences good and bad. Talking provides information about the situation but makes you friendly to an enemy. Fighting wears down resources but hurts a foe. They've fought the Knaves before and while they've never met the Knave in charge of this band he still knows who they are.

Third, there's a mystery to be solved. What's going on at the town? Why is Dusty turning into a monster? If they talk to the Knaves then where are all the miners and people from the town and where did the constructs and abominations come from? They care about some of the missing people and a mystery is interesting to some of the players. I've hit what the characters care about as well as throwing out a general air of mystery to interest the players, not the characters, to be interested.

The players choose to talk and make nice with the Knaves which gets them some help and information. They learn the Mining town is a ghost town and some strange and horrible things have been coming out of the mines. They also learn that the refinery that's just outside of the mine has been working day and night. If they would of fought the Knaves things would of been very different. They wouldn't have the information but the kingdom of Ester would of probably rewarded them if they survived for eliminating another member of the Knaves.

The encounter also put stress on the players because of the time constraints for Dusty and I used it to push the players. Whenever they seemed to be dawdling I would have Dusty cry out and shift around a lot or have the players notice he was getting closer to changing all the way. I don't hammer NPC's the players care about a lot but it worked in this case. It was even better when they failed to save Dusty at the end and he turned into a choker. The dice just happened to play out that way as they failed to turn him back on the last roll. They put him down themselves after that. Boy have they hated the mindflayer ever since them and keep trying to kill him. He's probably the most wanted villain in the game which I've been able to use as motivation. They care about it so I use it.

Well, I hope this helps you folks out there trying to grab your players attention even more than you do already. Please leave a comment, especially one about your experiences with giving players choices and using there motivations.

Good Gaming and Good Night.

Sunday, August 22, 2010

Iron DM My Way (Part 3)

Iron DM My Way (Part 3)

This is the third part of what I did to finish second in my first time competing in the Iron DM competition. See the previous three posts for what Iron DM is and what idea's and GM tools I've used up to this point.

Into the sewers they went and the first thing they did was craft a dowsing rod to find the source of the bound spirit. So instead of giving them a map and a dungeon to explore I went with a more scene based situation due to the limited amount of time. The dowsing rod was a good excuse for this style since they were following it and I could have the rod lead them where ever I wanted.

This next part is an exercise in combat encounter design. Now I did this on the fly but when I'm actually crafting an adventure or scenario and I know I'm gonna have a set piece this is how I usually craft them.

I love Otyugh's. They're the monster garbage disposals of the D&D world. They love eating filth and I've always used them as a cities sewage disposal system. Why would they attack the city folk when they can get an all you can eat buffet right where they are.

So my set piece is in a main sewage junction. There are two platforms in the middle of a large area filled with sewage. There is a small walkway on the outside. Luckily no one noticed there should have been a boat or platform to get across to the middle platforms where the controls are for draining sewage. There are also ten pipelines leading away from this area. The dowsing rod is pointing to the north where there are three pipes but there are also three Otyugh's in the sewage that pop up and surprise the PC's as they all fail their spot checks. Combat begins.

I explain the sewage is thick and probably deep, not that they can see through it, and they'd have to swim to get across it. In response the rogue and Half-Orc Barbarian decide to climb the pipes on the walls and use them as monkey bars to get across to the controls taking some Attacks of Opportunity on the way. They make it and start fussing with the controls as the other characters are fighting with the Otyugh's. The environmental impact is the sewage is giving the Otyugh's cover and hindering the movement of the PC's. Round 2 has the Sorcerer using a scorching ray which partially explodes in his face but really hurts the Otyugh too from all the methane gas in the sewer. It also has the Rogue and Half-Orc working the controls to drain the sewage from the area which keeps the random effect of having a rush of sewage come in from one of the tubes on round 3, removes the Otyugh's cover, and makes it easier to move about the sewers.

The Cleric hears multiple somethings coming from the other sewer tunnels. These are undead ratmen controlled by Wyran. They have the lighting surrounding them like the Bodak did. I send ten of them and give them 20 hp or a couple of solid whacks, an attack of +5 and 1d6+1 damage plus 2d6 sneak attack damage and an AC of 18 Reflex +5, Will and Fort +3. I do this all in my head in about 4 seconds and jot the notes down as I continue to run the game.

I made some of this up on the fly and decided some during the break but my encounter has some interesting terrain features that can and were manipulated, changing terrain features with draining sewage, environmental effects with methane gas, a possible random element with the sewage rush that never happened, and a three way fight between, undead ratmen, Otyughs (who would of but never got to attack the undead rat men), and the PC's. There was also a fire started from alchemists fire which kept spreading throughout the fight. The players were inventive and I used the "Yes And" rule or the "Yes But" rule at times. All in all it was a fun encounter.

Next I used a trap skill encounter borrowing heavily from the 4e model. There was a series of crushing block traps in the hallway just outside of the entrance to the Knaves hideout. Generally a simple Spot plus disable device check would be sufficient but that really isn't much fun so I decided to make it a group activity and a scene instead of a tactical situation drawn out on a map. Yes the Rogue spotted the traps but now he has to guide the party past them all giving them bonuses to the tumble or Dex checks to not step on the trapped areas. This is a long area filled with these pressure plates. Next problem they come too is a long swath of pressure plates the Dwarf Cleric can't get across without help or jumping a long ways. There solution is to toss him. Unfortunately the two strong girls toss him to the scrawny Sorcerer. That was almost disastrous except for a deft catch by the Rogue.

After that they found the secret door the the Knaves hideout. They go inside, find the living area empty, check out all three doors leading from the living area and find necrotic energy behind them all with the strongest coming from the door leading west. They don't open the north or the south door but the Half-Orc watches the southern door. Behind the western door is Molly's bedroom. It has a bed, large mirror (which is the prison of Wyran Watts), desk, carpet, and a wardrobe.

So here's what I decided. In the north room is the former leader of the Knaves now dead and controlled by Wyran Watts. His name is Mordicai Booth and he's a Pyromancer. The PC's know who he is from one of the NPC cards I have out. He's gonna throw down some fire spells. I jot down the numbers quick as 42hp, AC 18 and I make up the rest. The elven warrior is Calderon Mistwalker who is also dead and under Wyrans control. The PC's also know him from the NPC cards. I jot some numbers down for him too. AC 24, hp 58 +10/+5 to hit and 1d8+5 damage and I make up the rest. I also make some decisions about the ritual they need to complete and inform them.

Step one - Draw a magic circle.
Step two - Get the mirror in the circle
Step three - Light the circle on fire to close it.
Step four - Chant the ritual to it's completion.

All the while Wyran will be summoning shades, throwing around black lightning, and trying his best to not be dragged into the circle by using his magic. He's also animated the carpet in Molly's room to attack and squeeze the life out of anything it can wrap around. I make some stats up for it too.

The following is a summary of the encounter. If your not interested feel free to skip to the next paragraph.

Once three of them are in the room Wyran manifests in the mirror and starts with some bad guy monologue while I have them all roll initative. From the north room pops the pyromancer who flings fire spells. From the southern door comes the elven swordsman who squares off with the Half-Orc. Wyran starts flinging magic from his mirrored prison and the carpet comes to life and tries to get the Rogue but misses. Shades are summoned and turned. The carpet gets the fighter but her swords damage the carpet as they poke out of it. The Rogue leverages one of the blades to cut the carpet in half but breaks the Fighters arm in the process. The elven swordsman knocks a piece of the Half Orcs skull off which the Dwarf Cleric catches, replaces, and heals just before the Half Orc cleaves the elven warrior in half. All the while the pyromancer is laying down heavy fire spells and the sorcerer is trying to drag the mirror into the magic circle they created while having a battle of magic and wills with Wyran. Finally they get the mirror in the burning circle and start chanting the spell when Wyran has the pyromancer use an empowered fireball to blast everything including itself in a last ditch effort to save himself. It almost works as half the party goes down but the Sorcerer stays up and finishes the ritual banishing Wyran to the plane of Shadows and the good guys save the day.

Well that's the game that I ran to finish second in the Iron DM tournament this year at GenCon. In the final encounters I just tried to use terrain, non hp reducing challenges, and exciting action and descriptions to make the game as interesting as possible. I love me a good slugem out fight but just adding in a few more elements make encounters really shine.

Good gaming to ya and good night.

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Iron DM My Way (Part 2)

So the first hour was over and I was running a game for five strangers I'd never met before. For more information on what Iron DM is all about and what I did for the first hour refer to the previous two posts.

To begin the game the first thing I did was hand each player an index card and told them to look to the person to your right and write down a couple sentences about how you met them. Part two of this little group building exercise was to look at the person to your left and tell me why you still adventure with them. This little trick builds relationships between the characters quickly and gives a starting point for the acting and personality parts of the game for the players characters. Hopefully you end up with a party of adventurers that already have a couple of stories between them instead of a group of random strangers at a bar.

The second thing I did was hand out five cards with Location, Theme, and Face on them or Name and Theme. I asked each player to fill out one of these cards. I'd already filled out some of these with places and NPCs the Characters would be familiar with. For example:

Location: Drunken Dragon Inn and Tavern
Theme: A haven and place to gather information and stories.
Face: Old Job - Storyteller

I stole this little trick from the Dresden Files RPG. The idea is if the players have a hand in creating places and NPC's in the world they're playing in they'll be more invested in the game. Giving a little creative freedom goes a long way.

I get back the locations, NPC's, and group building cards and read them off. This is what I end up with.

- A Dwarven cleric who's following around a female half-orc Barbarian trying to save her soul after saving her life in a bar fight.
- The half-orc barbarian and a human fighter who went to girl scout adventurers camp together when they we're younger.
- A human rogue and half-elf sorcerer with mutual respect for one another after they almost killed each other. They still don't trust one another all that much but keep company for their mutual advantage.
- The dwarven cleric and the human rogue with ideological differences.
- The fighter and sorcerer who enjoy a mutually beneficial adventuring relationship.

From the places and people cards I get a seedy bar that deals in black market trading, a magic shop, and a halfling who's afraid of Half-Orcs.

Now I begin the game. I know I'm going to have an investigation portion so I want to start fast. I do with the Bodak chase encounter. It's supposed to be a warm up encounter and killing all the monsters isn't the point. The goal is to catch the Bodak and save Molly. I use some city tiles that I bought in the vendor room the day before. It's a chase across the city walls with zombies crawling up the sides of them to get in the PC's way. I go in for the theatrics so when ever someone rolls a die I do my best to describe what happens in an over the top heroic way. If you know who Nick Logue is then you know what I'm talking about. If not do a You Tube search for him. I still use his burning hands description to this day.

Here's a recap of the scene. The ladies blended up Zombies as the rogue tumbled his way onto the Bodak's ghostly steed. The cleric and the sorcerer discovered a strange black lightning surrounding the Bodak and learned the lightning was a spell causing the Bodak to obey someone. The sorcerer and cleric dispelled the necromancers control with combined dispel magic and consecration spell. At the same time the rogue succeed in wresting the Bodak off the ghostly steed with a make shift garrote from some rope in his pack as the horse had jumped into the air over a fountain. The rogue succeeded because he lassoed the top of the fountain with the rope that he'd wrapped around the Bodak's chest and neck. The Bodak crashed, the rogue grabbed Molly and landed on his feet, and the adventures succeeded. Not only did they succeed but they didn't kill the Bodak who they learned was the raised Davol Cardigan and got some information from him before releasing his soul to the afterlife.

From there the investigation began and I got to use the players halfling NPC, the seedy bar, and the magic shop. There was a lot of play acting and improvised storytelling. I listened to the players, took there ideas, and ran with them. For example the Half Orc really wanted to make a spot check for something suspicious so when she rolled I made up a cloaked suspicious figure who escaped from the Drunken Dragon when she saw it. It flew to a sewer grate and sunk threw it leaving the cloak behind. This made her feel important and gave some information as to where the game was going.

To implement the investigation part of my game where the group wasn't together I used scene cuts to keep everyone involved. After about five minutes or when I came to a place of tension I would cut to the next person and ask them what they we're doing. This kept people from being out of the game too much. I learned how to implement this trick from a friend of mine named Drew Smith. He loves all things Chthulu and uses this storytelling device to great effect in those games to build and release tension.

One of the highlights of the scene cuts was the rogue and the sorcerer infiltrating the Arcanum (local wizards school) by using deception and sneakiness. The Sorcerer pretended he wanted to join the school to study "real" magic since he knew the mages of the Arcanum were snobs. While the sorcerer ran interference the rogue snuck by some traps and into the part of the school where they kept their books on necromancy. This culminated in the rogue having to think fast as the sorcerer and the head mage of the Arcanum went to the same room on a tour of the place. Quick thinking, a few laughs, and a little kept them from alerting the mage to the rogues presence allowing him to escaped with an important book needed to banish the ghost of Wyran Watts. This event gave me plenty of opportunity to jump back and forth between the characters just like in a TV show so when I asked the other characters what they were doing I got scenes to break up the action. Here are a few of them.

- The fighter went shopping and then asked the shop keeper about undead in the area. She learned a lot more were around lately and they seemed to be coming from the sewers.

- The cleric went to the magic shop and talked to the owner who was a sly salesman. He wanted to make money, that was his motivation, so when ever the cleric asked for anything the sly wizard would respond with some price for the service or goods. I did this in my TV salesman impersonation. He found out about the ghost from the salesman and how they might deal with it.

- The half-orc barbarian sat and heard a story from Old Job at the Drunken Dragon before spotting the cloaked figure spying on the place.

Aside from pacing, another point of all these little excerpts was every players got to do something important for the investigation by discovering vital information about what to do next or confirming that information. Furthermore I let them come up with a lot of the idea's about how to get the information. I knew where I wanted them to go and what I wanted them to have but I felt it was important for them to give me how they got there. It might seem like railroading but when the characters choose the how it's rewarding for them, or so I believe. I don't think DM's should just tell players things, the players should find out themselves.

Well, this is getting to be a mouthful so I'll leave it at that for this post. To end I'll say the players found all the information they needed and got the ritual to banish Wyran and it only took about an hour and fifteen minutes. Next time they delve into the sewers to find Wyran and end the threat.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Iron DM My Way (Part 1)

So at GenCon 2010 I was in Iron DM. See the previous blog post for what Iron DM is. I came in second and here's what I did to get there.

So my three words were Level six core. Luckily my players figured out level six core meant make 6th level characters only using the core books. The next thing I did was decide on the adventure I wanted to run in basic. My three elements were Bodak, Bedroom, and Banishment. I was kinda feeling Urban adventure and a little mystery to give my players more than a monster bashing experience so I wrote on my note book "Urban adventure ok?" which the players approved of and got to work.

First I came up with the plot. If you don't want to read about the expanded plot there is a short summary after it so feel free to skip this paragraph and go to the next. A local thieves guild (the Kingshaven Knaves) the PC's are associated with in an amiable manner had a member go rogue on them six months ago. His name. Wyran Watts. An amazing lightning mage who wanted more power and betrayed the Knaves on a job for some potent necromantic books. The Knaves with the help of the PC's killed Wyran before he could summon up a powerful specter and take his power. Unfortunately the Knaves lost a member and friend named Davol Cardigan. The twist is Wyran was killed but ended up being bound to his standing mirror which was used as part of the ritual to bind the specter. The knaves kept the mirror and Molly O'Reily, one of the Knaves, put the mirror in her bedroom. Little did she know Wyran was bound to it. Over time Wyran learned to move from his mirror to others and having learned a great deal from the necromantic books and partially succeeding in absorbing the specters ability, had enough power to start raising undead and working towards getting released. He could only move to mirrors within the city of Kingshaven. When the adventure begins Wyran has raised Davol as a Bodak to kidnap Molly O'Reily who has a bracelet which is needed to free Wyran from the mirror. Once Wyran is free he can have his revenge on the players characters for their part as he's already dealt out his revenge on most of the Knaves.

The Short version
Crazy vengeful ghost mage wants out of his mirror prison and to kill the PC's for their part in putting him there.

So I have the plot now I need the spine. The spine is a rough guideline of the points I need to hit to get the adventure to it's end. I have what are called Core Clues here which are from the Gumshoe system by Robin Laws. It's also used in the Trail of Chuthulu game written by Kenneth Hite. A core clue is a clue the players are going to get as long as they ask for it or about it and never need to roll. Sometimes they just get it automatically because it's hard to miss. The idea is not to tell them what the clue means but give them information and let them come up with their own answers. Think of CSI or Law and Order. The investigators always find the clues and the story comes from trying to figure out what they mean and tracking down the leads.

Opening scene - Chasing the Bodak down on the walls of kingshaven.
Core Clues - The Bodak is acting strange and has a black lightning all around him. If they question the Bodak instead of killing him out right they learn he was Davol Cardigan. Once a Knave and Molly's Lover.

Davol can tell them his orders were always around a mirror.

Investigation - I wanted them to have a couple step process for the investigation but the ultimate goal was to learn that Wyran watts is the mastermind, is watching things through mirrors, is a bound ghost, and finally, can't be killed or exorcised but can only be banished to the plane of shadows. These are all Core Clues I wanted in the game and I left it pretty open as to how the players would find this information. I basically listened to the characters idea's and improvised situations. To prompt them I made up some locations and NPC's they knew on index cards so they could pass them around and see the names, feel, and inhabitants of the places. More on where I got this idea from later and how I used it to invest the Players in the game some more.

Having the plot points for the investigation I move onto the more D&D fight type dungeon crawl stuff. I figure two combats and maybe a trap styled encounter they need to over come if time warrants. I put the knaves hideout in the sewers because I want an Otyugh fight as the first encounter. Otyugh are basically large tentacled garbage disposals, plus they're my favorite D&D monster. I put that on the spine after the investigative parts. The trap is a sewer corridor right outside the knaves hideout where there are crushing block traps. It's a Molly O'Riely design so if they save her and ask for her help they can by pass the situation. For the final battle I use Molly's bedroom where a sort of a skill challenge from 4e plus a fight at the same time happens to banish the ghost of Wyran from the mirror.

So that's what I did in the first hour plus a few idea's jotted down and cards made to help invest the players into the game. That'll be in the next post.

Friday, August 13, 2010

Iron DM 2010

I love running games. It's kind of my thing or at least the thing I do best so I wanted to find out how good I actually am. To find out I went to GenCon this year and competed in Iron DM.

What is Iron DM?

Iron DM is a judged format similar to Iron Chef of food network fame. In the 2010 iteration of the competition seventeen competing GM's were given a table of five random strangers they'd never met before, three random elements, and one hour to come up with an adventure to run for the five strangers.

In that hour the players had to make a character based on the guidelines their DM gave them. The catch is the DM can only say three words. The other catch is the GM can write anything or communicate in any other way they'd like to the players as long as they don't speak. The people running the competition didn't tell us that until about half way through and only told us because a competitor asked for a rules clarification. I thought it was hilarious. After the hour of character creation and adventure design the DM's ran the game for the table of strangers for four hours with a 15 minute break in the middle. After four hours the players were given sheets used to score the DM's on rules knowledge, (Basically did we let the rules get in the way of having a good time), excitement for the game, and several other categories including, was the DM Iron. I can only speculate to what that means but it has something to do with awesomeness I'm sure.

Aside from the players at the table there are wandering judges who check on the games and keep their own scores. I imagine they're the tie breakers.

I finished second and am happy and disappointed at the same time. The winner, Steven Helt (AKA Ancient Sensei), is an amazing DM and deserved to win using every element from the last 5 or 6 years of the competition in his adventure.

So I was the 1st place loser of the Iron DM competition of 2010. You can bet your ass I'll be back next year to try and take the title. In my next post I'll talk about what I did to come in second and just as a preview, the Iron DM competition is run using the 3.5 D&D rules set, this was the first 3.5 or Pathfinder game I've run in well over a year. I'm not really a fan of the system but I do love the idea of this competition.

Let your mind be Illuminated
Chris "The Light" Sniezak

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Why are Zombies so cool?

I'm part of a group known as the Buffalo Gamer Society and we're having our first all day gamefest. It has a zombie theme. This got me thinking about zombies. Why are they're so cool these days and how can we use them in games? This is what I came up with:

1) Zombies are interesting backdrops to telling stories about people.

Zombie movies are really about people and how they react under duress. As the saying goes "stressful situations reveal true character". There isn't a much more stressful situation that having hordes of undead people trying to rip your head off so they can get a little refreshment.


2) Zombies used to be people

Every zombie used to be a human being and having humans, even if they're dead, eating humans is creepy. Take this a step further and have some of the zombies be people the characters were close too and you have drama.


3) There are always more

No matter how many zombies might get killed there are always more coming from somewhere. They are legion and they keep adding to their ranks as yours die out. It's only a matter of time before they over run everything.


4) Infection creates tension.

Once your hurt or even just get a little blood in you from one of the infected it's like a ticking time bomb. Your dead, you just haven't got there yet. That causes a sense of doom. Once you have doom you can give them hope. The anti virus is out there somewhere. This can cause tension, drama, and interesting character choices. What is a character willing to do and how far will they go to get that anti virus. (See point 1)

I think this is one of the places where fantasy loses out. There aren't too many examples of infection causing people to turn into zombies in fantasy literature or games. The Warcraft universe is the biggest exception I know of. I would suggest using that trope in your games some time. Invent a disease track, have only a few ways to get rid of the disease, and see what happens. It'll add another layer to your games.

Well there's my short list on zombies. I hope you enjoyed it and feel free to add to it. I'm sure I missed a lot of things.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

D20 Light Storytelling System

Last night I had the pleasure of designing a Role Playing Game in less than 5 minutes and play it. It was a lot of fun and I just stuck to one premise.

Make failure as interesting as succeeding.

This was primarily a storytelling game with a narrative control element to it. The mechanic used is a simple d20 roll. If you get an 11 or higher you succeeded, 10 or lower and you fail.

The character sheet looked like this:

Name:

What do you do?:

What do you wear?:

What do you have?:

List three things your good at:

Wounds:



The questions told the PC's what they had on, (What do you have?) gave an idea of what they knew how to do, (What do you do?) gave a little insight to their personality, (What do you wear?) and told us three things they were really good at.

There is a mechanical element to these questions.

The what do you wear question is more of a RP thing but has mechanical applications. An example would be your character is wearing plate mail so maybe it's harder for him to be hit by the baddies but if he tries to do something involving moving quickly or quietly it'll cause him a bit of a problem. Maybe another character is wearing nice clothing but is trying to go slumming to get information. This could lead to her being attacked for money or the poorer folk not trusting someone who's of better means than them.

If you try to do something within the realm of what you do there's no penalty or bonus to your role. If you try to do something your good at you get a +2 to the roll. If you try to do something outside of your abilities you get a -2. Of course the more ridiculous the thing you try the more appropriate the penalty will be but the rewards for succeeding are much greater and as I said earlier, failing is supposed to be just as interesting as succeeding.

The item limit should be whatever seems reasonable for the game. Any time you want to have an item you don't have you roll. This needs to make sense for the situation. If you succeeded you've always had it and can do what you wanted to do with it, if you fail the GM decides what you actually had or what actually happened with the item you were using.

Each character starts with three wounds which you can use as hits or whatever is appropriate for the game you run. These decrease as the story dictates; you get munched on by a lion, you're shot, an anvil falls on your head. Whatever hurts your character.


Narrative Control

The mechanic of narrative control described for items is used for most of the rolls in the game. If you succeeded you choose what happens or the GM describes something beneficial to the succeeding side. If you fail something cool happens but not exactly what you wanted. This could mean the attempt wasn't quite as effective as you wanted it to be or it works but you're hindered in some way. Whatever variations you can think of.

Only roll dice if it is dramatically appropriate to the story. Don't roll dice to unlock a door unless there's a good reason which means there's a cool failure scenario associated with the roll.

For enemies I used two types. Hordes and single enemies. A Horde is a large group of enemies. Really as many as you want. Single enemies are tougher bad guys maybe with names, maybe their just really ugly. Both have 3 wounds. The nice thing about a Horde is failed rolls against them can still allow for a few to die in a cool way so players don't feel like they did nothing because totally missing sucks.

Group initiative is another big thing. Just have the bad guys roll and take the average and compare it to the average of the player group. Then go back and forth until the conflict is resolved.


Here's the rules break down in short:

- Pick a Genre.
- The players fill out their sheets.
- Roll dice when dramatically appropriate.
- 11+ is a success and gives the roller narrative control. 10- gives the opposing side control. Natural ones mean something dramatically bad happens and natural 20's mean you critically succeed at your task.
- Initiative is always average of the group vs average of the other group.
- Make failure as cool as success.
- Trying to do something your good at grants a +2 bonus.
- Trying to do something in the normal realm of possibility for your character gives you no penalty.
- Trying to do something your not familiar with gives you a -2 penalty.
- The GM can decide to up the difficulty of a roll based on how insane the idea is but remember that failure is supposed to be just as cool as success.
- If you want something to happen for a dramatic or beneficial purpose roll the die. If you succeed you get what you want. If you fail the other side gets to decide but remember it has to be interesting for the story.
- If what your trying to do would end the story in a way that isn't fun or cool it automatically fails.

Those are the rules for my D20 light Storytelling System


Note: If any player tries to rules lawyer these rules put him in his place. This game is supposed to be light hearted and meant for one shot situations. There is no “winner” in RPG's and this game is no exception.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Drinking and Gaming

I like having a beer now and then. I'm no brewing aficionado but I'm starting to figure out what I like and what I don't. IPA's not so much. Stouts I'm down with. Lagers are good. I like a wheat beer now and then but I can't drink them all night. So what does this have to do with gaming?

Well, gaming is a social activity and drinking is a social activity. Since there are such things as drinking games. Why not do both at the same time? Play a drinking game while playing your RPG of choice.

Here are some basic rules you can use:

My suggested guideline. The GM should take the role of the designated driver. This doesn't mean he shouldn't drink, just that he doesn't follow the drinking rules the players are under.

- If your game has critical successes then you drink when you get one.

- If your game has critical failures then you drink when you get one.

- If your game has a special situation or rules, such as drawing the Joker in Savage Worlds, then you drink when it happens.

- If your game is combat heavy you drink whenever you kill something.

- If your game is based off of overcoming situations you drink when you overcome them. This would be a GM call.

- If your character would die and you don't want that to happen you can chug the beverage of your choice to avoid death.

- If you character would just fail you can drink to have him succeed.

- If you do something interesting in the game that everyone enjoys you can tell someone else to take a drink. This would be a GM call.

- If you want to fail a situation to create a more interesting situation you can take a drink and do so.

- If a bad guy taunts you, comes up with some kind of witty repartee, or berates you and you have no comeback, take a drink.

Well I hope this provides some added fun to your game and remember. Don't drink and drive and don't drink too much.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Philosophy of Gaming

So for my first post I'll be talking about my personal gaming philosophy. I figure it's a good place to start to introduce myself. By the way my tag might be Midnight Gamer but my name is Chris Sniezak. I'm ok with people knowing it.

So my philosophy. Like most people I believe gaming should be fun. If it's not fun then why are we doing it. So the next question would be how do I have fun? I like Role Playing Games. It's what I live and die for as far as my gaming life goes. The idea of crafting a story with a group of people and entertaining them for the time we are together is what relieves my stress, gives me a sense of accomplishment, and makes me happy.

I am an entertainer when I get behind the screen. That's how I see myself. I'm there to entertainer the players and give them a good time. Be that heavy role playing, tactical combat, interactive storytelling, or improve theater, I do what it takes. I've thrown myself into walls, yelled at groups in character, crafted terrain, and hand made miniatures out of Styrofoam and pipe cleaners when I couldn't afford them. You name it and I've either done it or would do it to make the game as entertaining as possible. That's what I believe.

When I'm playing in a game I need to do my best to play the character I'm portraying and involve everyone else who's playing too. I do this by asking them their opinions and question who they are and what they believe. I do this in character to attempt to make the game more immersive. Sometimes I'll confronting them if their actions go against what my character believes. I try to keep the antagonism low when I do this but sometimes it makes for great drama.

Whether I'm GMing or playing I look for characters stress points and try and push those buttons. It's those stress points that create drama and choices which makes stories happen. Of course there is always the plot of the game that is going on which adds for another level so then you can get multiple levels of story going on at the same time. If they can all connect in one big web, without seeming forced, then you've created something compelling the players should be invested in.

Well I guess that's enough for now,
Good gaming.