Thursday, August 26, 2010

Choice and Motivation

I do love running games. It's what I do the most. So get better at running games I've done a lot of reading of forums, blogs, and books and I've come to some important conclusions and found most people agree on the things you should do and not do. One of the big ones is RPG's shouldn't be railroaded games. Don't dictate the story to your players. You shouldn't write out a script. If your gonna run a game like that then go write a screen play.

Well ok. I know what not to do but no one really told me how to avoid this? I feel a lot of people gloss over that part with there advice. I don't know why. Maybe no one has ever quantified it well enough for everyone to agree on. Maybe there are many different styles and ways to avoid dictating story. I don't really think there are. I think it boils down to a couple things.

Choice and Motivation.

If you can give your players choices, especially ones motivated by who their characters are and what the characters care about, then your players are helping craft a story about them. So how does one craft a scenario to give their players choices that help in crafting the story? This is how I would do it.

Set up a situation where the antagonists to your players are trying to accomplish something and the players goals are opposed to the antagonists.

If this seems vague to some of you it is and by design. It's a concept you can use and apply to any style of game. So how do you implement this idea? Find out what your players motivations are, what they care about, and what interests them. Then make the antagonists goals the same as the players motivations, threaten what the players care about, or surround the game with what the players are interested in. You will create tension and conflict in your game developing drama and stress leading to action and choices.

So there's the concept and here's an example of how I implemented this idea to motivate the characters of a campaign I'd been running. The setting is fantasy and here's the Plot.

A mind flayer has a hidden lab in the mines of a mining town. He's been doing flesh warping experiments on the local wildlife, the random lost child who wanders into the mine, and the occasional miner who doesn't come back from a bathroom break. He's been given the go ahead by his boss to take the whole mining town and turn them into a flesh-warped army. Using his constructs and flesh-warped creations he manages to subdue or kill every person in the mining town in one night and turn the place into a ghost town with his constructs as guardians. The mines also serve as a raw material resource and the mind flayer plans on getting as much out of the mine as possible before the kingdom interferes. He has time since the mind flayers boss is keeping the kingdom busy for as long as possible from the inside. If nothing happens to interfere with the mindflayer it creates several hundred aberrant creatures and begins to expand from the mining town into the surrounding area causing more problems.

The players get involved when they're asked to find out what happened to an agent of a secret council they're friendly with. He'd stopped sending communications a week and a half ago and was stationed in the mining town. I'd set this up previously since the players had been to the mining town before and made friends with some of the locals. They were especially fond of a young boy named Dusty. It is also important to note that in the first story arc of the game the primary opponents to the players were a band of robin hood like rogues called The Knaves of Belard and the mining town is on the edge of their territory. They'd stopped a Knave plot but not the organization as a whole.

The first encounter sets the stage for the rest of the adventure. The players run into Dusty who's running through the woods of the Belard forest being pursued by some of the Knaves of Belard. Dusty is being pursued because he's slowly changing into an aberrant creature known as a choker. The Knaves have been doing everything they can to contain the horrors that have been leaking out of the Mining town. One of the things they've learned is once you start changing you can't change back. This isn't true but the Knaves haven't found a way to reverse the effects yet.

So in the first encounter I've given the players some choices and stresses.

First, an NPC they're fond of is changing into a monster. They have time but not a lot to try and find a way to change him back. It's someone they care about and for some saving this kid is part of there character motivation. Making up for things they've done in their past. Righting wrongs. Stuff like that.

Second, they have to either convince these Knaves to let them try and help Dusty or fight the Knaves. Both have consequences good and bad. Talking provides information about the situation but makes you friendly to an enemy. Fighting wears down resources but hurts a foe. They've fought the Knaves before and while they've never met the Knave in charge of this band he still knows who they are.

Third, there's a mystery to be solved. What's going on at the town? Why is Dusty turning into a monster? If they talk to the Knaves then where are all the miners and people from the town and where did the constructs and abominations come from? They care about some of the missing people and a mystery is interesting to some of the players. I've hit what the characters care about as well as throwing out a general air of mystery to interest the players, not the characters, to be interested.

The players choose to talk and make nice with the Knaves which gets them some help and information. They learn the Mining town is a ghost town and some strange and horrible things have been coming out of the mines. They also learn that the refinery that's just outside of the mine has been working day and night. If they would of fought the Knaves things would of been very different. They wouldn't have the information but the kingdom of Ester would of probably rewarded them if they survived for eliminating another member of the Knaves.

The encounter also put stress on the players because of the time constraints for Dusty and I used it to push the players. Whenever they seemed to be dawdling I would have Dusty cry out and shift around a lot or have the players notice he was getting closer to changing all the way. I don't hammer NPC's the players care about a lot but it worked in this case. It was even better when they failed to save Dusty at the end and he turned into a choker. The dice just happened to play out that way as they failed to turn him back on the last roll. They put him down themselves after that. Boy have they hated the mindflayer ever since them and keep trying to kill him. He's probably the most wanted villain in the game which I've been able to use as motivation. They care about it so I use it.

Well, I hope this helps you folks out there trying to grab your players attention even more than you do already. Please leave a comment, especially one about your experiences with giving players choices and using there motivations.

Good Gaming and Good Night.

1 comment:

  1. Sumbitch mind flayer needs a serious attitude adjustment.

    ReplyDelete